Ask a doctor - Which is better, mastectomy or lumpectomy? Why?

Mastectomy and lumpectomy are both common treatments for breast cancer but which one is better depends on the individual patient s circumstances A mastectomy involves surgically removing all of the breast tissue while a lumpectomy removes only the affected area Each treatment has its own risks benefits and long-term implications that must be considered when discussing with your healthcare provider what is best for you A mastectomy may be recommended in cases where there are multiple tumors or if more extreme measures need to be taken to reduce the risk of future recurrence due to larger tumor size or aggressive type of cancer cells Additionally mastectomies may involve reconstruction surgery afterwards which can help restore some of a patient 39 s body image confidence On the other hand lumpectomy operations tend to have fewer side effects since only a limited amount of healthy tissue needs to be removed This means recovery times are shorter and scarring less noticeable however it also means more frequent follow up visits as smaller amounts of tissue can 39 t always guarantee removal of all cancerous cells present at diagnosis stage Ultimately whichever procedure is chosen depends on factors such as tumor location and size as well as whether lymph nodes must also be removed as can often happen during mastectomies Patients should talk openly with their physicians about their medical history in order to determine together what form of treatment will work best for them given their individual circumstance

Q. Which is better, mastectomy or lumpectomy? Why?

Doctor Answer is medically reviewed by SecondMedic medical review team.

Answered by Secondmedic Expert

Mastectomy and lumpectomy are both common treatments for breast cancer, but which one is better depends on the individual patient’s circumstances. A mastectomy involves surgically removing all of the breast tissue, while a lumpectomy removes only the affected area. Each treatment has its own risks, benefits, and long-term implications that must be considered when discussing with your healthcare provider what is best for you.

A mastectomy may be recommended in cases where there are multiple tumors or if more extreme measures need to be taken to reduce the risk of future recurrence due to larger tumor size or aggressive type of cancer cells. Additionally, mastectomies may involve reconstruction surgery afterwards which can help restore some of a patient's body image confidence. On the other hand, lumpectomy operations tend to have fewer side effects since only a limited amount of healthy tissue needs to be removed. This means recovery times are shorter and scarring less noticeable; however it also means more frequent follow up visits as smaller amounts of tissue can't always guarantee removal of all cancerous cells present at diagnosis stage.

Ultimately whichever procedure is chosen depends on factors such as tumor location and size as well as whether lymph nodes must also be removed (as can often happen during mastectomies). Patients should talk openly with their physicians about their medical history in order to determine together what form of treatment will work best for them given their individual circumstance.

Sweet and Healthy: How Watermelon May Protect Your Heart
09 Oct, 2023 By: Secondmedic Expert

Understanding MRI Scan, benefits, diagnosis, sideeffects
27 Sep, 2021 By: Second Medic Expert

Sleepless Nights and Heartache: Exploring the Alarming Connection Between Insomnia and Cardiovascular Events
09 Oct, 2023 By: Secondmedic Expert

Going Beyond the High: Uncovering the Heart Health Risks of Cannabis Use Disorder
09 Oct, 2023 By: Secondmedic Expert

Sweet Showdown: Sucralose vs. Sugar - Navigating Their Impact on Your Gut Microbiome
11 Oct, 2023 By: Secondmedic Expert

10 Ways to Prevent Covid 19: Prevention of Coronavirus
04 Apr, 2020 By: Secondmedic Expert